I'll try to write down all my observations about the locations I visit, including lists of notable games, pictures of the layout, and general opinions on the quality and maintenance conditions of the machines.
Here is a breakdown of my rating standards for the critique categories:
Fun value (machine variety, amount of machines, condition, and quality:)
1 star "Complete crap": A very sparse collection of machines, with little to no entertainment value, either due to lack of maintenance, prevalence of redemption machines instead of entertainment ones, or other reasons.These kinds of places aren't really worth the trip in the end. Unlikely to have classic machines or pinball tables due to their higher maintenance demands.
2 stars "Pretty bad": A lower-quality assortment of games, lacking anything significantly interesting or well-maintained worth playing. These places aren't recommended, but could still be a bit fun for those with lower expectations. These arcades may have classics and pinball tables, but don't expect them to be in terribly good condition.
3 stars "Not bad": A nice collection of fun games, boasting a decent amount of variety in their genres. If you're in the area of this arcade, it's worth a visit. These arcades are more likely to have classics and pinball tables, although they may be in a bit of disrepair compared to higher-rated arcades.
4 stars "Great": A very good assortment of fun games, covering quite a few types of genres and themes. When you're in the mood for a game, these are prime material. If these arcades have pinball or classics, expect them to be in good shape.
5 stars "Awesome": A excellent amount of variety in all the games, with obvious care put into their maintenance and upkeep. These arcades are pretty likely to have classic games and pinball tables, spanning both popular titles and possibly more obscure games, all in good repair.
Hospitality (facility conditions, game organization, and staff helpfulness):
1 star "Unprofessional": An unclean atmosphere, inexperienced or practically nonexistent staff who won't be able to help with malfunctioning games, and sloppy organization of games and other related items.
2 stars "Bad": Slightly dingy facilities and atmosphere, attendants with little training in maintenance , and rather strange game organization.
3 stars "Ok": Nothing special, but not a disaster either. Expect attendants to be reasonably helpful, but don't count on them to be able to fix it right away if you get a pinball stuck or something. Organization of games is decently thought out, but a little clumsy at times.
4 stars "Welcoming": Helpful and knowledgeable staff, clean facilities and sensible organization, possibly divided into eras or genres.
5 stars "Very hospitable": Smart staff capable of fixing problems quickly, very clean conditions, and well-thought out machine organization.
Final rank (pretty much my general opinion of the location, taking into account the other factors):
1 star: Don't bother going to this location.
2 stars: Unless you're in very close proximity and just have to play a game, there are much better places to visit.
3 stars: You could probably find better places, but this is worth a try if you're in the area.
4 stars: This arcade is an excellent choice for those looking for a game. If you're looking for some games, and it's nearby, don't pass it up.
5 stars: This place is worth visiting alone, either for the quantity and variety of the games, or for any historical machines they may have.These locations are a destination in themselves for many arcade lovers.
Anyways, if there are any issues in my system, please tell me. I hope to begin writing about locations soon. If you're interested, be sure to check back when I make a new entry!